[OVNI-SCIENCES] ...Crop cricle

[Franck THOMAS]

Bonjour,

Je transmets ce message de la part de Roberto (R.Labanti at ads.it) qui n'est pas arrivé
à le faire passer sur la liste.


C'est une réponse au dernier message de Sundeye.

Franck. 
===========================================================================================

Sorry for this mine in English, but my wrote French is awful... (also my
wrote English, yes: thank you very much...).

A PDF file of the article

***
Grassi, Francesco, Cocheo, Claudio, & Russo, Paolo (2005, Summer). Balls of
Light: The Questionable Science of Crop Circles. Journal of Scientific
Exploration, 19(2), 159-170

Abstract - Three papers published by W. C. Levengood (1994), W. C.
Levengood and N. P. Talbott (1999) and by E. H. Haselhoff (2001) suggested
the involvement of some kind of electromagnetic radiation during the
creation of crop circles. Here we discuss the methods and conclusions of
the three articles, pointing out the misrepresentation of the experimental
protocols, the misleading application of statistical procedures, the
arbitrary discarding of unwanted results and the weakness of the proposed
physical model to the suggested hypothesis. In particular, we show that
Haselhoff’s conclusions are
unsubstantiated and do not prove the involvement of an electromagnetic
radiation source in the creation event.
Keywords: crop circles—balls of light—electromagnetic radiation—statistical
models—stem
***

could be retrived from the following link:

http://www.cicap.org/crops/

Amicalement,
Roberto

>
> ------------------------------------------------------------------------
>
> Sujet:
> Re: [OVNI-SCIENCES] Re: ...Crop cricle
> Expéditeur:
> R.Labanti at ads.it
> Date:
> Fri, 24 Jun 2005 18:38:35 +0200
> Destinataire:
> <Debat at ovni-sciences.net>
>
> Destinataire:
> <Debat at ovni-sciences.net>
>
>
>Bonsoir,
>
>Sundeye wrote on 24/06/2005 13.26.03:
>
>  
>
>>Il est dommage car cet
>>article parle des points scientifiques de l'étude de Haselhoff et
>>    
>>
>d'autres,
>  
>
>>et répond à pas mal de questions.  Je ne peux pas le coller dans un
>>    
>>
>message
>  
>
>>parce qu'il y a des tableaux.
>>
>>Il n'est pas encore en ligne, mais le sera bientôt je pense. Je
>>    
>>
>l'enverrai
>  
>
>>par mp à ceux qui veulent la lire, en attendant la configuration de la
>>liste.
>>    
>>
>
>  
>